The lesson of South Africa and the courage of discernment. At the center, the decisive question: is artificial intelligence an instrument of destruction or a path to peace?
The second appointment in the cycle of online round tables dedicated to the encyclical Magnifica Humanitas of Pope Leo XIV was held on 12 November 2026, promoted by the Justice, Peace and Integrity of Creation Commission of the Comboni Missionaries of the Italian province. After the first meeting on the theme of work, this time the focus was peace, with a title that already posed an urgent question: “Artificial Intelligence, Peace and Social Justice.” The guests of the evening were Giulia Bordin, advocacy officer of Pax Christi International, and Father Fabio Baldan, a Comboni missionary who spent about twenty years in South Africa.
Two biblical icons for a choice of civilization
The proceedings opened with a reference to the two biblical images that Pope Leo uses in the encyclical: the tower of Babel, built with a logic of pride and power, and the rebuilding of Jerusalem, carried out through patience, safeguarding the human and promoting a common construction of the good. Artificial intelligence can be placed at the service of both logics: on the one hand it can be a powerful factor accelerating destruction; on the other it can be an effective instrument for promoting the common home and the common good.
Hence the question: in an international climate in which the law of force often prevails over the force of law, how can we counter the tendency of an AI controlled by those who pursue the path of pride and power?
AI is not neutral: it is an environment, not just a tool
The response began from a fact that the encyclical itself underlines: artificial intelligence, like any technological tool, is not neutral. It depends above all on who develops it, who maintains it and who uses it, because behind this development and this use there are very specific interests. But there is a further aspect that distinguishes AI from other technologies: it does not remain merely a tool, but also becomes an environment. An environment in which we are immersed and which influences our way of being, of relating, of acting in the world, of gathering information, and therefore also the way in which, in the end, we make decisions.
The main risk identified by the encyclical is that the human being may be transformed into something no longer human, reducing complexity—including that of the relationship with creation—to mere transaction, to mere transfer of data, to mere calculations aimed at efficiency. Hence the need to avoid two symmetrical extremes: demonizing AI or hailing it as the instrument par excellence. We must find the right middle ground in our relationship with it.
At this point it is essential to outline the systemic context: AI is strongly monopolized by certain states, companies and multinationals that control not only artificial intelligence and its progress, but more generally the model of development in which we are inserted. An extremely aggressive model, based on speed, on acceleration, on the pursuit of unlimited wealth and on power dynamics that end up affecting international relations as well. The consequence is what is called the crisis of multilateralism: institutions created to govern the changes of the world-system now find themselves in a situation of inadequacy, while the dynamics of power and acceleration can barely unlock the situation any longer.
The question, then, is not so much whether and how to use artificial intelligence, but whether the current system is capable and ready to welcome this instrument and use it to the best for the common good. The proposal is to focus on a slowing down: to give ourselves the possibility of discernment. Something that, if we also associate artificial intelligence with military instruments, would not be possible.
Autonomous weapons: human control, international law, responsibility
The second passage of the conversation concerned the arms race and the sophistication of weapons made increasingly effective by AI, with algorithms commanding weapons in place of human beings. Three fundamental problems emerge. The first is the absence of human control: It is not only the moment when the button is pressed and the weapon launches, but the entire process that comes before: the ability to assess whether a situation justifies an attack or not. With an automated system there is a risk of nullifying any analysis that a human being could make, and therefore any individual could become a target, by error or through a lack of analysis.
The second issue concerns the risk of violating international humanitarian law. We must build a structure that allows us not only to intervene on the consequences but to prevent them: to use the instruments of international law we have and to establish rules that guarantee preventive analysis and a transparent process. The third point is the attribution of responsibility, linked to transparency across the entire chain: not only who gives the order that the automated system then executes, but the entire chain of production and management, who chooses which technology to use and when. Hence the hope for an international legal instrument covering all of this, to discourage certain types of weapons and, once prevention is underway, to work toward a conversion of the instrument: no longer for lethal weapons, but for the common good, for cooperation and dialogue.
War is not a destiny: the lesson of Mandela
The second part of the meeting focused on South Africa, starting from paragraph 124 of the encyclical, which recalls the end of apartheid after the liberation of Nelson Mandela and his choice not to entrust the future to hatred. The context was very tense and explosive, with the assassination of Chris Hani, a leader of Catholic formation, which had brought South Africa to the brink of civil war. It was mainly thanks to Mandela and his appeals for calm that an escalation was avoided.
South Africa was the typical case of what in the Church we call a structure of sin: a system of injustice built in a very refined, accurate and legal manner, which collapsed without plunging into a bloodbath. Apartheid was not only racial prejudice: it was a structure of sin thought out, elaborated and constructed, with laws that classified the population by race and created puppet states. The South African Catholic bishops also condemned it in 1957, and many religious paid a high price.
On the theme of nonviolence, it is noted that the word does not appear in Magnifica Humanitas, but Pope Leo uses it in about ten other documents. In South Africa the history of nonviolence begins with Gandhi, who lived there from 1893 to 1914, developing satyagraha, the force of truth, resistance without hatred. This philosophy then entered the liberation movement with Lutuli, president of the ANC and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, a Christian convinced of the nonviolent path. With Mandela things become more complicated: after the Sharpeville massacre of 1960 and the banning of the ANC, he chose armed struggle, limiting himself however to striking infrastructure and not people. His greatness emerges much later, when he is freed in 1990, after 27 years of imprisonment. Everyone expected some desire for vengeance, and instead he chose reconciliation and forgiveness over revenge.
There followed the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, which gave victims the possibility of being heard and, with limits and partiality, the power to grant amnesty on condition of full cooperation. An experience exported to other African countries and beyond.
Why does the Pope choose this example? There are three reasons. First, because history is not a destiny: structures, even the most solid, are human works and can be changed by human choices. Second, because peace is not simply the absence of war: Leo speaks of a “disarmed and disarming” peace, a logical thread uniting the various themes of the encyclical. Finally, because peace always passes through concrete people: there was not only Mandela, but millions of people with him, and there was also de Klerk, the president of the governing party, who experienced a certain conversion.
South Africa today and the challenges of AI
However, the shadows on the South African reconstruction process cannot be hidden. The corruption that marked the years after Mandela, social hardship, the enormous inequality between poor and rich always manipulated for political ends, the xenophobic violence of movements such as Operation Dudula, which, in the wake of youth unemployment exceeding 33%, points to migrants as the scapegoat. It is clearly a manipulation of social hardship for political purposes, as unfortunately happens in many countries today.
As for AI, South Africa is the leading African country by number of users (20-23% of adults), but its use is mainly economic. Unfortunately, no use—or at least no planning—has yet been announced at government level. However, an artificial intelligence factory exists and chatbots are being created in African languages. The problem always remains whether it ends up in the hands of a government or a monopoly. The government attempted to pass a law, but it remained blocked.
From the empty table to the civilization of love
The Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons is an example of multilateralism that works when it includes voices normally excluded. Today, at this diplomatic table, the very people who suffer the effects of decisions are often missing. The Church can contribute significantly, with its ability to bring the local level to the international one and to interpret the situations of the poor of the world.
On the front of publicly funded models, we must insist on the educational aspect and on citizen pressure, as well as on the need for upstream regulation. LLMs are based on enormous quantities of data, and precisely in the choice of these sources and the way they are managed there are enormous problems from an ethical and social point of view. Hence the call to remove artificial intelligence from the monopoly of private interests through a multilateral effort. The Stop Killer Robots campaign, active since 2013, should also be highlighted as a reference for a regulatory system that limits the lethal use of these systems.
Concluding with the words of Jesus, we must be “as simple as doves and as prudent as serpents”: we too must know how to use, with cunning and for the good, this powerful instrument that human beings have been able to place at humanity’s disposal, to build, as the Pope says, the civilization of love and not Babel.


